 |  | 
The NYTimes
Opening Campaign, Netanyahu Invokes
'Will of the Nation'
By DEBORAH SONTAG
J ERUSALEM, Dec. 10 —
Having disappeared from the
Israeli political scene for 19
months, former Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu returned
tonight in full, media- savvy
Netanyahu style. He flew in from
abroad, swept onto the evening
news and proclaimed his intention
to recapture first the Likud Party
leadership and then the office of
prime minister.
Back in the embrace of the
television cameras, Mr. Netanyahu
said Prime Minister Ehud Barak
should not be allowed to frustrate
"the will of the nation" by blocking
his ability to run for office.
Mr. Netanyahu said he would
work to brush aside the political
and legal obstacles to his
candidacy that were placed in his
path by Mr. Barak's resignation
from office today.
"The man who bypassed the will of
the nation while in power is now
bypassing its will in order to stay in
power," Mr. Netanyahu said,
giving a taste of his combat
readiness. "He is not resigning in
order to restore calm or stop the
Palestinian violence or to return
security to our people. Something
else is happening here: the most
cynical political trick in the history
of Israel. He is resigning in order
to prevent the people from freely
and democratically electing a new
prime minister and Parliament."
Still, for Mr. Netanyahu, who
commands a significant lead in
opinion polls, becoming a
candidate will not be as easy as
announcing his intention to run.
Mr. Barak indeed foiled his rival's
expected candidacy in an
unexpected political strategem this
weekend, and it will take
dexterous political and legal
maneuvering by Mr. Netanyahu to
survive Mr. Barak's move.
On Saturday night Mr. Barak wrested the political initiative from a
Parliament prepared to vote soon to dissolve and head toward new
general elections in late spring.
He announced that he would resign instead, forcing a special election
within 60 days for prime minister alone. Under the law for special
elections, the field of candidates is limited to members of Parliament,
which excludes Mr. Netanyahu.
Mr. Netanyahu, 51, quit his seat and the Likud leadership on the day that
Mr. Barak, 58, overwhelmingly defeated him for prime minister in May
1999. He then turned over the reins of a weakened party to Ariel
Sharon, 72, and fled politics for the life of a consultant and lecturer. In
the Israeli nationalist camp, there has been a steady drumbeat for his
return, especially since the eruption of the Palestinian uprising 10 weeks
ago.
But Mr. Sharon long ago discarded the idea that he was a mere
caretaker, and he now hopes to run for prime minister as the Likud
candidate — another stumbling block, although probably a minor one,
for Mr. Netanyahu.
Judging by the polls, Mr. Barak stands a much better chance against Mr.
Sharon, which clearly influenced his decision to resign.
Almost two weeks ago, when Parliament approved a draft bill to
dissolve, Mr. Barak said he would not fight the legislators' desire to
depose him. At the time, he also said he would not circumvent it by
resigning to keep Mr. Netanyahu out of the race.
At his televised news conference tonight, Mr. Netanyahu, whose
nickname is Bibi, gave a dramatic reading of Mr. Barak's words from
then: "I already beat Bibi, and I'm not afraid of him. The possibility of
resigning in order to neutralize him did not even pass through my mind for
a single moment."
But during the subsequent two weeks, Mr. Barak said, he came to
believe that many members of Parliament did not really want to undergo
new elections. He said he had decided not to "drag" them through a new
general election and to seek a fresh mandate from the people for himself
alone.
Those two weeks also featured a steady stream of opinion polls that
showed him losing badly to Mr. Netanyahu. The polls showed Mr.
Barak's Labor Party suffering a debilitating blow as well, and there was
discord within Labor. Mr. Barak changed his mind.
This afternoon, President Moshe Katsav accepted the prime minister's
resignation, which takes effect on Tuesday, and congratulated him for
seeking to determine at the polls whether the entire nation stands behind
him.
Mr. Barak, a tight smile darting across his face, quickly corrected the
Israeli president. In 1999 he sought to be the leader of "ev-er-y-bo-dy,"
as his slogan said. Now, his sights are lowered. "A majority," he said.
"For me, a majority of the people is enough."
Later today, by an informal vote, the Labor Party's central committee
swiftly chose Mr. Barak to be its candidate for prime minister. That
ended a brief turbulent period within the party during which a dovish
faction had considered running a candidate against him for party leader.
With the election around the corner, there was no time for an internal
race, and Mr. Barak stood unopposed in today's show-of-hands vote.
Shimon Peres, a leader of the doves and a former prime minister, did not
attend the meeting.
"He was elected by a majority, and it was a democratic move," said
Avraham Burg, the speaker of Parliament, who abandoned the idea of
opposing the prime minister because of the accelerated election schedule.
Mr. Barak thus successfully quelled potential opposition within own
party, although there is still some discussion of the peace camp mounting
a third-party candidate. Israeli Arab lawmakers are also considering
fielding a candidate, which would be a serious blow to Mr. Barak. And
several Likud lawmakers are contemplating mounting a challenge to Mr.
Sharon if Mr. Netanyahu is not allowed to run.
But Mr. Barak's most daunting opponent is Mr. Netanyahu. Mr.
Netanyahu has two options for finding a way into the race. His followers
are pursuing both. First they are seeking to amend the law governing
special elections to allow someone who is not a member of Parliament to
run for prime minister.
That is a cumbersome route, because it requires fast-tracking a bill and
then earning an absolute majority of the fractious 120-member
Parliament. Such a bill could also face a court challenge; Israel has never
had a prime minister who was not also a member of Parliament.
Mr. Netanyahu seemed to be urging his followers down a different route.
He said he believed that Parliament should continue what it started two
weeks ago and take a final vote to dissolve itself.
In that case, Parliament's legal adviser ruled today, Mr. Netanyahu would
be allowed to run and elections for prime minister and Parliament would
be held simultaneously. It is widely expected that Feb. 6 will be the
election day.
But Israeli political analysts said tonight that it was far from certain that
there was majority backing for dissolving the house. Parties who fear that
they will lose seats are not eager. For instance, Shas, the rigorously
Orthodox party that represents working-class Sephardic Jews, is known
to be reluctant.
Leaders of Shas said they were awaiting a ruling from the rabbis who
guide them.
Indeed, spurred by Mr. Barak's maneuver, the political system spun into
a frenzy of activity today as the prime minister's associates and
opponents alike consulted legal advisers to determine what possible
paths lay ahead.
Many predicted that the complex legal issues would end up in court.
Inevitably, then, Israelis noted that having built their suburbs and
shopping malls on the American model, they were now mirroring the
disarray in the American political system.
"In an act of symbiotic identification, Barak has brought Israel into a
constitutional frenzy reminiscent of what is taking place in America,"
Chemi Shalev wrote under the headline "Act of Kamikaze" in the
newspaper Maariv. "The difference is that, one, there they have already
had elections and, two, there they don't know who has lost yet."
Similarly, Nahum Barnea, a columnist for Yediot Ahronot, writing that
"no trick from the law books" should prevent Mr. Netanyahu from
running if he is the favored right- wing candidate, asked, "What are we,
America?"
Latest interviews with Netanyahu (Hebrew)
interviews with Netanyahu (english)
Views of the current situation in Israel
Netanyahu Watches and Waits for His Opening
BIBI: THE BEST HOPE FOR PEACE
Letters to Netanyahu
|
|